Mosque for Doveton plan irks church

Not welcome: Doveton residents Noel Johnston, Eileen Lewis, Clive Ritchie, Margaret Monssen and Cynthia Bernardo on the site of the proposed mosque. Picture: Wayne Hawkins

By CAMERON LUCADOU-WELLS

ANTI-ISLAM crusader Daniel Nalliah and his evangelical Christian church are set to fight a plan to build an 11.5-metre-high mosque in the same street.

Mr Nalliah, a pastor at Catch the Fire Ministries, said his church was weeks away from building a $2 million base at 25 Green Street, Doveton.

He recently learnt of a planning application by an Afghan community group to build the Omar Farooq Mosque next door.

The church, along with more than 100 petitioners including adjoining residents, will formally object to Casey Council over the mosque proposal.

No objections had been raised against Catch the Fire’s church, which had been approved by the council, Mr Nalliah said.

Afghan-Australian Association of Victoria president Khaliq Fazal, when asked his opinion on the mosque, accused Mr Nalliah and his church of distributing “hysterical” anti-mosque leaflets to “agitate” neighbours.

He said the mosque was a “place for peace and for the worship of the same god that we all believe in”. 

“The Afghan community has a very good reputation and has assimilated well in a multicultural society since the 1860s. We’ve never had any problem with any other religions. We believe in Jesus Christ as well, so what’s the problem?”

SEE: Doveton mosque objections collected

Mr Nalliah — an outspoken figure who sparked outrage for attributing Black Saturday bushfires to Victoria’s abortion laws — said he did not know who was behind the leaflets.

He said his objections to the mosque trailed back to a long-running racial vilification dispute with the Islamic Council of Victoria over a Catch the Fire newsletter about Muslims and the Koran in 2002.

Mr Nalliah said he and his family received death threats during the dispute, which cost the church $600,000. “Not once have we said people should bust up a Muslim or burn down a mosque.

“We don’t approve of Islam as a religion but we love Muslim people. Islam teaches that those who follow other religions are infidels.

“It is a religion that doesn’t value freedom of religion. Having those same teachings right under our noses is counter-productive to our church.”

He claimed that homes vacated by “fed-up” neighbours would be bought up by Muslims, creating a “sharia [the moral code and religious law of Islam] zone”.

Casey planning manager Duncan Turner said the council would consider any public submissions “received up until it makes its decision”.

Muslims feel discriminated, study reveals

MUSLIMS have reported the most discrimination among any followers of faith, a university study found.

The Monash University study Mapping Social Cohesion 2012 surveyed areas in Greater Dandenong, Hume and two council areas in Sydney.

It found that in the past two years, 34 per cent of Muslims felt discriminated for their faith, skin colour or ethnic origin.

Islamic Council of Victoria director Nazeem Hussain said discrimination was already known in the Muslim community.

He said it was inflamed by the ongoing asylum seeker debate, which “plays on a racist kind of narrative” filtering top down from federal politics to wider society.

Greater Dandenong’s Islamic population has grown from 8667 to 13,600 in the decade to 2011. 

Imam Ibrahim Onerdic, of the Noble Park-based Bosnian and Herzegovinian Islamic Society, said he hadn’t heard of instances of discrimination in Greater Dandenong. He had known of Muslims changing their name to score a job.

Khaliq Fazal, president of Afghan-Australian Association of Victoria, said Australia was more tolerant than many other Western countries.

— Cameron Lucadou-Wells

What do you think? Post a comment below.

For all the latest breaking news, stay with this website. Also, follow
the Weekly  at
facebook.com/dandenongjournal or on Twitter 
@DandenongJournal.