DANDENONG STAR JOURNAL
Home » Patients ‘at risk’ during clinic blackout

Patients ‘at risk’ during clinic blackout

An Endeavour Hills medical centre spent five days ‘off the hook’ due to what appears to be a telecommunications bungle.

Dr Richard Weston, of Raymond McMahon Medical Centre, said its service provider Commander had suddenly stopped the surgery from receiving all incoming calls on Friday 11 January.

“It was only when a patient came to the surgery and informed us that we were alerted.”

The situation was potentially life-threatening, with the centre on-call 24 hours a day.

Despite being informed of the perils, Commander’s call-centre operators told the surgery that no technicians were available until the following Monday.

None arrived until the afternoon of Tuesday 15 January – and only then after the interventions of Narre Warren North MP Luke Donnellan, the Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman and radio station 3AW.

“It was an appalling situation,” Dr Watson said.

The debacle seemed to be related to the clinic’s switchover in services from Commander to Telstra scheduled for 21 January, he said.

Commander blamed Telstra for the service failure, but Dr Weston said he backed Telstra – which had been diligent and helpful during the transition.

The surgery was offered compensation by Commander but safety, not money, was the issue, Dr Watson said.

A spokesperson for Commander said they could not comment on the specific situation due to privacy concerns.

A Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman spokesperson said 16 per cent of the 20,433 small business complaints to the TIO in 2017-18 related to no phone or internet service.

She advised customers to first try to resolve the situation with their service provider before contacting the TIO.

“The Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman works with residential consumers and small businesses and their phone or internet provider to fix faults such as not having a phone or internet service by working with all the parties to resolve the complaint.”

Digital Editions


  • EPA, Veolia at odds over toxic-waste cell

    EPA, Veolia at odds over toxic-waste cell

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 228738 The state’s pollution watchdog says it remains opposed to a new toxic-waste cell at a controversial hazardous-waste landfill…

More News

  • Minister’s warm welcome to Wellsprings

    Minister’s warm welcome to Wellsprings

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 532816 Wellsprings for Women welcomed the Federal Minister for Multicultural Affairs, Dr Anne Aly, who saw first hand the South East-based centre’s efforts to…

  • Food for thought ahead of bigger Ramadan Night Market

    Food for thought ahead of bigger Ramadan Night Market

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 467847 Excitement grows ahead of the upcoming three-week Ramadan Night Market that promises to be bigger and better, but existing traders in Dandenong have…

  • Two men arrested after Wallace Road assault

    Two men arrested after Wallace Road assault

    Two men have been arrested following an assault in Cranbourne on the morning of Friday 6 February. Officers responded to reports of three men involved in a physical altercation on…

  • Opposition inquiry call rejected after peak-hour train disruption

    Opposition inquiry call rejected after peak-hour train disruption

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 183562 The State Opposition has called for a formal inquiry into Tuesday 3 February rail network disruption, where peak-hour disruption left thousands of Cranbourne…

  • Roadworks cause havoc for Casey commuters

    Roadworks cause havoc for Casey commuters

    Roadworks on a major Clyde North intersection has caused gridlock during peak hours for many Casey commuters, some saying that their usual 10 minute drive has taken them close to…

  • Looking Back

    Looking Back

    100 years ago 11 February 1926 The new “Keep to the Left Rule”, which the Dandenong Shire Council has not brought into force, is not very strictly observed in the…

  • What’s On

    What’s On

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 390730 Victorian Mosque Open Day Mosques open their doors to visitors on this annual open day organised by Islamic Council of Victoria. Venues include…

  • The power of self-acceptance

    The power of self-acceptance

    Intrinsic in feelings of hope is the acceptance of the self and then the acceptance of the situation with the faith that there is some benefit in it. This attitude…

  • Jail for armed carjacker targeting elderly driver

    Jail for armed carjacker targeting elderly driver

    A would-be carjacker who held a screwdriver to his elderly victim’s neck and threatened to kill him in a home driveway in Keysborough has been jailed. Petap Kong, 31, of…

  • Letter-to-the-editor: Who will grow the trees?

    Letter-to-the-editor: Who will grow the trees?

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 492338 This summer’s repeated 40-degree days have made one thing unavoidable: Melbourne’s suburbs are heating up, and trees are no longer decorative extras. Councils…