DANDENONG STAR JOURNAL
Home » Daughters ’set record straight’

Daughters ’set record straight’

Daughters of a deceased hospital patient have told an inquiry on 2 September that their mother ate I Cook Food sandwiches.

On their mother’s 89th birthday, Jo Woodstock and Fiona Wharry say they fronted the inquiry into I Cook Food’s closure to give their mother a voice and set the record straight.

They say their mother Jean Painter ate at least four packaged sandwiches at Knox Private Hospital – allegedly supplied by ICF.

On one occasion, she was unhappy with a serve of sandwiches. “They don’t taste very nice,” she said.

At the time, in early 2019, Ms Painter was living independently in a retirement village. Sociable, she had survived two bouts of cancer and was looking forward to living at least another five years.

On 13 January, she was admitted to Knox Private Hospital with gastroenteritis. She was on normal hospital food during her stay until 23 January, Ms Woodstock said.

She was placed on soft food after she was re-admitted with more severe illness on 25 January.

This was counter to a report by a Knox food inspector Ray Christy, who was told by Knox Private that Ms Painter had been on soft food only.

That is, sandwiches prepared in the hospital kitchen, not by ICF.

Ms Painter died in “great pain”; Ms Woodstock told the inquiry.

“Her deterioration was one of the most distressing things to witness.

“The vision of her suffering will always haunt us.”

Ms Woodstock said Chief Health Officer Brett Sutton’s evidence to the inquiry in 2020 was the “most balanced and accurate” in regards to her mother’s death.

She said his “fast and immediate” closure of ICF was “appropriate” and “possibly saved the lives of others”.

Digital Editions


  • Ramadan Night Market returns

    Ramadan Night Market returns

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 467847 As the holy month of Ramadan is fast approaching, so is the buzz and excitement for Dandenong’s already-famous…

More News

  • Young leader attuned to social harmony

    Young leader attuned to social harmony

    Migrating from United States to Australia at a young age, volunteer Atifa Ahmed was taken aback by the country’s sense of community. Awarded the joint Young Leader of the Year…

  • Kingston Cr lodges ‘stop bullying’ action against Monitor

    Kingston Cr lodges ‘stop bullying’ action against Monitor

    A Kingston councillor has lodged legal action against one of the state-government appointed municipal monitors at the council. A ‘stop bullying’ order has been sought against John Tanner AM at…

  • Melbourne’s youth gangs face 24/7 disruption and quick arrests

    Melbourne’s youth gangs face 24/7 disruption and quick arrests

    Victoria Police laid 4,300 charges against Melbourne youth gang members last year, including almost 400 for the possession of weapons such as machetes and firearms. A range of exhaustive disruption…

  • New honour for history’s ‘treasure’

    New honour for history’s ‘treasure’

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 531111 The news of today is the history of tomorrow – Greater Dandenong’s newly-inducted Living Treasure Christine Keys is fond of saying. For many…

  • Plastics recycling at risk of collapse: ALGA

    Plastics recycling at risk of collapse: ALGA

    City of Casey has backed calls for urgent national packaging reform, amid rising levels of recyclable plastics dumped in landfill. Recently, Australian Local Government Association (ALGA) president Matt Burnett stated…

  • Hope is the invisible gift

    Hope is the invisible gift

    The sacred gift of life can be likened to a river. From its quiet beginnings to its meeting with the vast ocean, the river glides through peaceful valleys, then rushes…

  • Series of car thefts at Fountain Gate Shopping Centre sparks concern

    Series of car thefts at Fountain Gate Shopping Centre sparks concern

    Fountain Gate Shopping Centre has been a hotspot for a string of car thefts over the last few months with many shoppers are now choosing not to park their cars…

  • Looking Back

    Looking Back

    100 years ago 4 February 1926 Items of Interest Police Paddocks The Ferntree Gully Shire Council has agreed to co-operate with the Berwick Council in endeavouring to have 1,000 acres…

  • What’s On

    What’s On

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 321360 Reuse and Recycle Drop Off Day The event gives you the opportunity to get rid of any larger unwanted household goods suitable for…

  • Nawed creates place of belonging

    Nawed creates place of belonging

    Once a shy young boy unsure on his future pathway, Mohammed Nawed Sarwari has found his true self after immersing in Greater Dandenong’s community programs. Selected as the joint Young…