DANDENONG STAR JOURNAL
Home » Puppies as Christmas gifts? Good intention, bad idea

Puppies as Christmas gifts? Good intention, bad idea

If you’re thinking about giving your loved one a puppy as a gift this Christmas, Dogs Australia urges you to “think twice”.

“Puppies can’t be exchanged, returned or put in the cupboard if the Christmas present isn’t the right fit,” said Hugh Gent OAM, president of Dogs Australia, which promotes responsible dog ownership.

“And sadly, many impulsively bought gift puppies will end up in shelters.

“There’s a huge misconception that pets make great Christmas gifts when, in fact, they don’t. Sure, it’s exciting to see someone’s face when they first see their ‘gift’ but once the novelty wears off and the reality of owning a dog sinks in, it’s often a different story. Owning a dog is a big responsibility.

“Remember, you’re gifting an obligation – and you need to be confident the recipient will be able to provide for the dog beyond puppyhood and for many years to come. Dogs require commitment: they depend on us 24/7 for their care and they need a lot of exercise and attention.”

It’s also crucial to ensure a good fit between dogs and their people, which is why Hugh says it’s best to have someone choose their own dog – if they want one – rather than selecting one you think will be a good fit.

“Dogs have personalities just like we do, so it’s important to research the right breed that best suits your personality, your family and lifestyle.

“At Dogs Australia we promote responsible dog ownership – and animal shelters are already packed with homeless animals – and sadly, since the pandemic, more dogs have been surrendered because people can’t cope with them, don’t have time to look after them, can’t afford them, or have just lost interest. Never surprise someone with a puppy – it could backfire spectacularly.”

Six reasons why you shouldn’t give a puppy as a Christmas present:

Dogs are a long-term commitment

Owning a dog is more of a responsibility than a gift. Not only do they need a lot of care and training, but they also come with a lot of expenses. It takes time and commitment to own a dog. On average, dogs can live up to 13 years or more.

Dog ownership is time intensive

A dog’s not an ornament to be left in the backyard or a toy you can play with until you get bored. They need attention, love, training and exercise.

Owning a dog can be expensive

A dog requires food, toys, trips to the vet, medicine, pet insurance, training, holiday boarding, grooming and more. That can amount to thousands of dollars each year.

Are you sure they want a dog?

They might be allergic to dogs, not have the time or patience to care for a dog, can’t afford to care for a dog, do a lot of traveling, and they might not even like dogs!

You might accidentally end up buying from a puppy farm

If you are excited by the idea of buying a puppy as a Christmas gift, you might accidentally end up buying from an illegal puppy farm rather than a legitimate, reputable breeder. “Puppy farms tend to have more readily available puppies due to the sheer number they breed – but this comes at a price,” said Hugh. “Often these pups are poorly socialised and more at risk of health problems. Their parents are housed in poor conditions and the ‘business’ owners aren’t focused on the welfare of their dogs. A puppy should be purchased from a registered breeder.”

Returning the dog could jeopardise its life

If your loved one doesn’t want a puppy, they might end up surrendering it to a pet shelter, and this could potentially put the animal’s life in danger. If no new owner adopts the dog, it might then be euthanised.

Digital Editions


  • Seagulls legends honoured

    Seagulls legends honoured

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 533225 **One of the most awesome things you’ll see in local sport is the new mural on the wall…

More News

  • Alleged car thief faces 60-plus charges

    Alleged car thief faces 60-plus charges

    An alleged serial car thief has been charged after using electronic key reprogramming devices to steal at least 25 cars across Melbourne, police say. The 27-year-old faces more than 60…

  • Dandenong downed by impressive VPC debutant century

    Dandenong downed by impressive VPC debutant century

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 528966 Dandenong (203) was on the receiving end of a milestone moment amidst a defeat to finals-bound Melbourne (6/308) at Shepley Oval in round…

  • Noble falls painfully short

    Noble falls painfully short

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 531172 A shakeup in the finals mix came in the form of a Croydon (210) upset as Noble Park (146) faltered at home in…

  • Critical nursery in need of a home

    Critical nursery in need of a home

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 532813 A volunteer nursery helping to propagate the South East’s disappearing flora is now itself under threat. Greenlink Sandbelt Nursery has been supplying the…

  • Three arrested following alleged stabbing in Narre Warren

    Three arrested following alleged stabbing in Narre Warren

    Three teenage boys were arrested last week following an alleged stabbing in Narre Warren. Police believe the altercation took place between a group of boys at a shopping centre on…

  • Galloping into a New Year with style

    Galloping into a New Year with style

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 531866 Under a blazing blue sky, thousands of revellers celebrated the Year of the Horse at the annual Springvale Lunar New Year festival. More…

  • Sign of the times: Record crowd expected at Bring Your Bills

    Sign of the times: Record crowd expected at Bring Your Bills

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 403433 February is piling up with credit card debt, back-to-school bills and higher interest rates – so the time is more than ripe for…

  • Funding call to further combat racism

    Funding call to further combat racism

    An anti-racism support network has provided its first insights after a year of documenting racism across the state, the first of its kind in Australia. The network, established in 2025…

  • Socialists stake their claims for State Parliament

    Socialists stake their claims for State Parliament

    Victorian Socialists has revealed its candidates for the relatively safe Labor seats, Dandenong and Mulgrave in the upcoming state election. Both young candidates chant calls for change, saying the two…

  • A spot of kindness led by young local leaders

    A spot of kindness led by young local leaders

    A Casey-based Girl Guides group dedicated to empowering girls and young women has delivered a heartfelt show of support to local frontline volunteers. Narre Warren North Girl Guides recently visited…