DANDENONG STAR JOURNAL
Home » Merle fights on for aged-care change

Merle fights on for aged-care change

A Springvale community trailblazer Merle Mitchell expects “things are going to change” after delivering a powerful public condemnation of her experience in aged care.

Ms Mitchell, 84, appeared via video at the Federal Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety on 7 May.

She spoke out on understaffing, undertraining, the lack of challenging activities and a lack of empathy since moving to Waverley Valley Aged Care in 2016.

Speaking out is what she has done all her life, she later told Star News.

“Advocating for change is part of what I’ve done for a long time.

“We’ve got to make sure all sides of politics take up the recommendations that the Commissioner is going to make.”

She has had to learn to accept the regimentation of meals and showers, and the loss of contact with Nature.

“An aged care facility is not a home. It is an institution,” her submission stated.

Ms Mitchell says it was a “terrible shock” to move into aged care. There was the sudden loss of her way of life and independence. She couldn’t retain all the precious items that he had in her former home.

“It’s traumatic for me to not have those things that were part of my regular life.

“I can no longer reach out and grab an atlas if I hear something on the news.

“I can no longer reach out and get my favourite book.

“You lose your choice totally when you come into aged care. And that’s one of the things that needs to change.”

She told how there was no grief counselling offered when her husband and former City of Springvale mayor Eric Mitchell died. Instead there was an awkward lack of empathy from staff.

On another occasion, she suffered in agony for days yet staff repeatedly told her there was nothing wrong with her.

She was eventually hospitalised for three weeks with crushed discs.

The main problem is staff ratios – just one registered nurse for every 170 residents.

“There are just not enough staff for what needs to be done,” she told Star News.

“The number of falls in these facilities is just enormous.”

More funding and training is required, as well as better payment of staff.

“If you’re a child-care or an aged care worker – both ends of the life cycle – you don’t get properly paid.”

Ms Mitchell pays an extra $50 a day for “special services” such as a 30-minute exercise class, soup with her meal, and a newspaper.

“It’s all about money.

“One of the bad things that we did was to turn all this care into a private industry so it’s all about profit.

“Until we stop that we won’t get the change we need.”

A Greater Dandenong Living Treasure, Ms Mitchell is an aged-care advocate for Council On The Ageing (COTA).

She is involved in a new RMIT-developed training course for care workers.

She is a past director and founder of the Springvale Community Aid and Advice Bureau (now South East Community Links), as well as setting up Springvale Neighbourhood House and the Family Mediation Centre.

She is also a former president of the Australian Council of Social Service.

Digital Editions


  • The great AI content heist

    The great AI content heist

    In a recent Australian Financial Review opinion piece, “There is nothing creative about AI not paying for news content”, Rod Sims made a point Australia…

More News

  • Reliable Roos conquer Turf 2

    Reliable Roos conquer Turf 2

    “We set out a goal a couple of years ago to get back up to Turf 1 and I remember we got laughed at,” Coomoora captain Dean Krelle Coomoora capped…

  • Bears prey on the Bucks

    Bears prey on the Bucks

    Berwick ended dreams of a three-peat for Buckley Ridges after the Bears roared over the Bucks at Dandenong Park Oval on Sunday. Berwick became just the second team to defeat…

  • Knock out for Noble Park

    Knock out for Noble Park

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 531172 Noble Park’s (148) stunning fall from grace is now complete after a four-wicket loss to Werribee (6/152) in the Victorian Sub District Cricket…

  • Wonderful Wolff leads the Friday night pack

    Wonderful Wolff leads the Friday night pack

    The Mountain Dart League returned from its Labour Day weekend off in spectacular style in round five with 180s rolled our regularly and some great individual performances. In Division 1,…

  • Car rolled over in Dandenong Sth

    Car rolled over in Dandenong Sth

    Ambulance Victoria was called after a car rolled over in Dandenong South this morning. The incident occurred at around 9:30am on Tuesday 17 March. Advanced Life Support (ALS) paramedics assessed…