DANDENONG STAR JOURNAL
Home » ‘Un-Australian’: Community leaders condemn ‘no good Muslims’ speech

‘Un-Australian’: Community leaders condemn ‘no good Muslims’ speech

South East leaders have condemned recent public remarks by One Nation leader Pauline Hanson, suggesting there are “no good Muslims.”

“Such statements are harmful and risk reinforcing stigma, exclusion, and division within our multicultural society,” Wellsprings for Women chief executive Dalal Smiley said.

“We stand in solidarity with Islamophobia Register Australia and others who have highlighted the damaging impact of rhetoric that generalises or vilifies entire communities.”

Ms Smiley said Islamophobia had real and documented consequences, particularly for Muslim women and children.

“Muslim women — especially those who wear visible markers of faith such as the hijab — experience disproportionate levels of verbal abuse, harassment, and public hostility.

“Children are also affected, facing bullying, social isolation, and diminished wellbeing.

“These experiences undermine safety, belonging, and participation in community life.”

Wellsprings for Women supports migrant and refugee women from culturally and linguistically diverse communities across Melbourne’s South-East and is an active member of the South East Anti-Racism Network.

“We see first hand how respectful dialogue and inclusive leadership strengthen social cohesion,” Ms Smiley said.

“Public commentary carries influence.

“At a time when many communities are observing important cultural and faith traditions, it is vital that public discourse reflects responsibility, fairness, and respect.”

Ms Smiley said Australian Muslims were valued members of society — contributing as professionals, parents, volunteers, and community leaders.

Greater Dandenong councillor and six-time mayor Jim Memeti, who is Muslim, condemned Ms Hanson for her “completely and utterly false” and “un-Australian” remark.

He said her “Islamophobic” statement may consititute unlawful “hate speech”.

“I think someone who sits in Federal Parliament and is speaking like this is completely un-Australian. All she is doing is supporting division.

“In Greater Dandenong we continue to work really hard to bring communities and faiths together, to have really nice social cohesion.

“We put our arm around our fellow Australians whether they’re of Hindu, Christian or Islamic faith and we support one another.”

Cr Memeti cited Ahmed al Ahmed, a hero who disarmed one of the gunmen during a terrorism massacre at a Hannukah celebration at Bondi Beach last year, as one of “thousands and thousands of good people of Muslim faith”.

“Australia is a country of immigrants – everyone I know loves this beautiful country, they wouldn’t want to live anywhere else.

“If (Ms Hanson) is going to create division and turn people against each other, that’s not a good leader in my view.”

Bruce MP and multicultural affairs assistant minister Julian Hill posted on social media that “Pauline Hanson’s comments about Muslim Australians are digusting”.

“That sort of dangerous chaos and hate has no place in Australia.”

Ms Hanson, who was recently suspended from the Senate for wearing a burka in Parliament, is well known for claims such as Australia being at risk of being “swamped by Muslims”.

Her party One Nation is currently riding high in the polls, and recently recruited former Nationals leader and Deputy PM Barnaby Joyce.

Digital Editions


  • Free fun at Keysborough’s Big Picnic

    Free fun at Keysborough’s Big Picnic

    Pets and ground rugs are going to pack out Wachter Reserve for Keysborough’s Big Picnic. The park party has an expanded program of activities, performers,…

More News

  • Dandenong volunteer with ‘impact’

    Dandenong volunteer with ‘impact’

    A Dandenong woman has been recognised for her 18 years of volunteering to help migrants and refugees settling in Australia. Khadija Karimi is one of five women from multicultural communities…

  • Noble Park woman charged over allegedly stolen pup

    Noble Park woman charged over allegedly stolen pup

    A woman has been charged over an allegedly stolen puppy that was recovered by police in Noble Park. Dora, a 10-month-old black cavoodle, was allegedly untied from a pole on…

  • Successful Chinese Lantern Festival celeberations

    Successful Chinese Lantern Festival celeberations

    The Edelweiss Casey Choir celebrated the Chinese Lantern Festival on Sunday, with an event titled Blossom of Harmony: Lantern Festival Gala. Many attended the Hallam Community Theatre to highlight the…

  • Hit to helmet proves costly

    Hit to helmet proves costly

    **Just when you thought the Premier relegation battle between DEVON MEADOWS and UPPER BEACONSFIELD couldn’t get any closer, there was an odd moment towards the end that may have helped…

  • Maskiell, Munro and Midge

    Maskiell, Munro and Midge

    DAVE: Good morning boys, welcome back to another edition of LTS. It’s always great when I get to wear my Collingwood polo on a Monday morning after a big win…