DANDENONG STAR JOURNAL
Home » Forget Guru Nanak Lake – let’s name a suburb Nanakville instead!

Forget Guru Nanak Lake – let’s name a suburb Nanakville instead!

A lake (re)naming?

A Parliament and politicians uneasy about a petition.

A community confused.

And once again, grassroots racism rears its ugly head!

Let’s be clear – this is no longer about a lake.

This is about Australia’s identity crisis – loud, unfiltered, and raw.

In 2023, an unnamed (ungazzeted) man-made lake in Berwick Springs was renamed Guru Nanak Lake, in honour of a man who preached peace, equality, dignity, and service to humanity.

Values Australia claims to hold dear.

But more importantly honouring the Sikh Community who serve the community whether it is bushfires, floods, lockdowns or everyday needs.

Now in 2025, a parliamentary motion to revert the name – prompted by a noisy petition – has torn the scab off something deeper.

Some argue it is about process. Others say it is about consultation.

But the loudest voices…

“Mass immigration is destroying Australia! ”

“Go back to where you came from.”

“We do not want our places named after your people.”

This is racism. Not subtle. Not hidden. Loud, destructive, and emboldened.

The lake had no official “original” name.

Berwick holds no sacred significance – it was the name of a farm owned by a wealthy white settler who imported the title from Berwick-upon-Tweed in the UK.

Yet now, after a peaceful renaming in honour of a global figure, and respected Australian community the community erupts in outrage?

This is not heritage protection. This is performative rage.

This is not community concern. This is targeted cultural bullying.

On the other hand, if politicians are so eager to win the Sikh vote, why not go all in?

•⁠ ⁠Name the next suburb Nanakville.

•⁠ ⁠Build a Guru Nanak train line.

•⁠ ⁠Open a Nanak Stadium with a canteen serving butter chicken pies, Punjabi chai and Mango Lassi.

But we are not interested in tokenism.

Sikhs did not ask for this renaming.

We do not need a lake to validate our belonging.

We have been here for generations.

Our ancestors were Sikh Cameleers (lumped in with Afghans) who helped open Australia’s interior.

We forged desert trade routes, collaborated with Aboriginal communities, and served in both World Wars.

We have paid our dues in grit, sweat, silence and taxes.

We do not need to prove anything. We are already part of this nation’s story.

Our message: Withdraw the name, not our dignity.

We say this to the Sikh leadership and the Government: Revert the name. Not out of embarrassment but out of conviction.

Let us not allow a lake to become a lightning rod for hate.

But do not think for one second that racists get a free pass.

This episode has exposed something Australians have been walking on eggshells around for too long.

Racism is not rare. It is not underground. It is thriving.

Other ‘western’ countries have named streets after Sikh Gurus. Why can’t we?

Earlier this year in New York, a street was officially named “Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji Marg Way” – honouring the ninth Sikh Guru, known for his advocacy for freedom, justice, and human dignity.

If the United States – with all its own issues – can recognise the value of cultural contribution, what is stopping us? Is it pride? Or is it prejudice?

We Do Not Want a Lake. We Want Legacy.

Sikhs do not need monuments. We want meaning. We want Australia to grow up. To define itself. To educate itself. To stop walking on eggshells around racists and cultural conversations.

Forget the lake. Forget the panic. Forget the politics.

And if someone does name a suburb Nanakville, let it come with:

•⁠ ⁠A cricket ground,

•⁠ ⁠A Bunnings and Fish & Chips,

•⁠ ⁠A community garden run by the old Aunties (wisdom),

•⁠ ⁠And a big sign that says in ENGLISH: “Everyone is Welcome.”

Because that is what being Australian should mean.

Digital Editions


More News

  • What’s On

    What’s On

    Portrait Drawing Beginner-friendly in portrait drawing, with artist Ariel De Ramos. Materials provided. Library membership is required to register. – Tuesday 20 January, 10.30am-12pm, Keysborough Community Hub 10 Villiers Road,…

  • 244-run stand leads Coomoora to victory

    244-run stand leads Coomoora to victory

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 440832 A remarkable 244-run partnership between Coomoora pair Krishan Alang and Jarrod Munday saw the side register a 92-run victory over Lyndale in the…

  • Noble knocked from perch

    Noble knocked from perch

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 525928 Noble Park (173) has experienced the sour taste of defeat for the first time in more than three months after being outplayed by…

  • Soft-plastics recycling boost in South East

    Soft-plastics recycling boost in South East

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 491853 More than 16,000 tonnes of soft and hard-to-recycle plastics will be recycled each year at four sites including Pakenham and Dandenong. The State…

  • Learner driver caught speeding at 226km/h on Monash Freeway

    Learner driver caught speeding at 226km/h on Monash Freeway

    Police intercepted a Narre Warren learner driver this morning after he was allegedly caught travelling over 220km/h in a 100km/h zone in Mulgrave. The 23-year old man was driving on…

  • Panthers prowl then pause

    Panthers prowl then pause

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 528966 Dandenong (6/242) will be playing for pride in the remaining three rounds of Vic Premier Cricket after failing to capitalise on a winning…

  • Hallam Kalora Park fit and firing

    Hallam Kalora Park fit and firing

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 528964 Hallam Kalora Park made it five wins in a row against Berwick on the weekend in round 10 of Dandenong District Cricket Association…

  • Monitors costing ratepayers small fortune

    Monitors costing ratepayers small fortune

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 243203 The state government has been criticised for the extension of municipal monitors at Kingston Council at an enormous cost of up to $1500…

  • High speeds in alleged stolen SUV, two boys arrested

    High speeds in alleged stolen SUV, two boys arrested

    Two boys were arrested after allegedly speeding at more than 200 km/h in a stolen SUV on Friday 16 January. Police say they observed the white Mazda SUV driving erratically…

  • Suspicious fires hit abandoned Dandenong properties

    Suspicious fires hit abandoned Dandenong properties

    Emergency services responded to suspicious fire in another abandoned property in Dandenong. It is believed an abandoned house on Woodlee Street caught fire about 6.30am on Tuesday 13 January. Fire…