DANDENONG STAR JOURNAL
Home » Dandenong Journal Letters to the Editor

Dandenong Journal Letters to the Editor

Re: Church ‘ruined my career’

The Holy Family protocols are nothing like a comprehensive child protection policy. Nor is the woeful Melbourne archdiocese’s ‘policy’ titled May Our Children Flourish. 

Compare them with the UK or Irish Catholic Church guidelines and readers will see just how woeful they are. How can these people think they can get away with such substandard responses to this dreadful problem. Who on earth was willing to put together guidelines without determining what world’s best practice would be? Don’t our children deserve the best? Don’t be lulled into thinking that the church is really doing all it should. It isn’t.

– Pam Krstic (via web)

Save our suburbs

The City of Greater Dandenong needs to adopt a zero-tolerance approach to development in this region to restore the balance that’s needed in this industry. 

The developers need to understand that they can’t keep going the way they are. Eventually they will run out of land and places to develop and our grandchildren will be left with a questionable legacy to deal with. The council must act now to take stock of what has happened and what needs to be done to save our suburbs from this scourge. It’s threatening our quality of life and even our very existence.

– Patsy Horne, Dandenong

Re: Call to ban hate preaching

I am a blue-eyed Australian who converted to Islam in 1995, and I’ve spent 55 of my 66 years in Doveton. I just want to point out some facts.

First, Daniel Nalliah claims he is an anti-Islam crusader — imagine if a Muslim used those words. He claims he is Christian, yet he protests against a place of prayer. He also makes reference to the holy Koran calling Christians infidels — before he plays the word game, he should read all the books of our one God. 

To be a good practising Muslim you must believe in Christianity. The fact is the church has lost its way and has been in decay for many years, while Islam is thriving. The Muslim people have a right to a prayer place, as does a church.

– Abdul Rahman, Dandenong

It seems that the most vehement opponents of the Islamic community are the recent migrants to Australia, such as Pastor Danny Nalliah and Cr Sam Aziz. 

Both adhere to the ‘peace and love’ doctrine of the teachings of Christianity. Where is the tolerance and brotherly love for ‘all mankind’? The very people they oppose (Afghans) are the people Australia is fighting to give democracy and freedom to from fanatics like the Taliban. 

As for Cr Aziz, he says there is not a single word in the New Testament that he couldn’t live with. How about St Paul’s advice in Timothy 2:12 : ‘I do not permit a woman to teach or to have authority over a man. She must be silent’. Hmmm, that sounds a little bit like misogyny. Isn’t the mayor a lady?

– AI Wadia, Hallam

Though this issue is controversial in nature, I question the values, morals and religious beliefs held most highly by Cr Sam Aziz especially in light of his treatment to me, his community members Jason Wilde, former councillors and residents. 

As a Christian, I treat all human beings equally, whatever their beliefs and physical differences. We are all children of God. I quote Ms Doughan, a member of the Casey Multifaith Network: “The best thing we can do is prove them wrong. We want to live our lives peacefully.”

– Paul Richardson, Endeavour Hills

What do you think? Post a comment below.

The Journal welcomes letters no longer than 250 words. All letters are subject to editing and must include a name, address and phone number. Post: The Editor, PO Box 318, Dandenong 3175, or email eastvoice@yourweekly.com.au. Post a web comment to any story at dandenongjournal.com.au.

For all the latest breaking news, stay with this website. Also, follow the Weekly  at facebook.com/dandenongjournal or on Twitter  @DandenongJournal.

Digital Editions


More News

  • Impact through education

    Impact through education

    Akademos Society has spent over a decade lending a helping hand to disadvantaged academic students in Afghanistan and Pakistan through financial support. It began after a group of young Hazara…

  • Noble nourishment and Falcons flounder as VSDCA resumes

    Noble nourishment and Falcons flounder as VSDCA resumes

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 527661 The dawn of a new year has seen continued success for an in-form Noble Park (7/159) after a comfortable three-wicket victory over Yarraville…

  • Panthers and Swans register strong victories

    Panthers and Swans register strong victories

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 383174 An unbeaten century from Dandenong’s Dhanusha Gamage led the side to its third win of the season in the Victorian Premier Cricket Firsts,…

  • Big switch on arrival for Metro Tunnel timetable

    Big switch on arrival for Metro Tunnel timetable

    The Metro Tunnel’s Big Switch timetable has been released which will integrate the new tunnel into Victoria’s train network. Minister for Public and Active Transport Gabrielle Williams released the new…

  • Alleged speeding crash ends on Star News office embankment

    Alleged speeding crash ends on Star News office embankment

    Passers-by intervened as an alleged speeding car came to grief outside the Pakenham Gazette (also Star News)’s office just after 4pm on Friday 9 January. Witnesses said the dark green…

  • Three arrested following racially motivated abuse in Dandenong South, police say

    Three arrested following racially motivated abuse in Dandenong South, police say

    Three people were arrested in Dandenong South over the weekend following an alleged racially fuelled abuse. According to authorities, a man and a woman were travelling in their car along…

  • A taste of West Africa

    A taste of West Africa

    A West African restaurant is the first to open up at the Dandenong Hub Arcade food court in a decade. The restaurant has established their second branch at the hub…

  • Aussie double at Southern

    Aussie double at Southern

    Southern Golf Club in Keysborough provided the perfect canvas for the nation’s number-one ranked amateur event last week with the 2026 Australian Master of the Amateurs attracting some quality young…

  • Wills stuns the Lions with 6/8

    Wills stuns the Lions with 6/8

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 512659 There were some remarkable individual performances across the Dandenong District Cricket Association (DDCA) Turf 1 competition on the weekend. Dandenong West’s Shaun Weir…

  • Fatal collision in Doveton

    Fatal collision in Doveton

    A man has died following a collision on the Monash Freeway in the early hours of Sunday morning. It is believed by authorities that the man ran into the path…